Just Plain Bill
Observations of a Substitute Teacher
IX
Holding the Hands of the Future
Just the other
day, as I was pondering a great question from one of my third-grade students, I
realized my students will be the leaders and decision-makers in a generation or
so.
We’d been talking
about robots, what they can do and what they can’t do. The discussion morphed
into the area of whether a robot had “feelings.” One student had seen the movie
2001,
Space Odyssey, and brought up the subject of HAL 9000, the robot that
accompanied the astronauts into space.
HAL had a
memorable line in the movie when he was asked to let Dave, the crew chief on
the mission, open the space ship door to let him in. HAL’s classic line was, “I’m
sorry, Dave, I’m afraid I can’t do that.”
This line from
the movie gave rise to Malika’s question, “Can HAL have emotions, ‘cause he
said, ‘I’m sorry…’ Doesn’t he have to have emotions to say that?”
Needless to say,
I didn’t have an answer to that question. Plus, I hoped the students would
discuss that question themselves – and they did.
This gave rise to
all kinds of research on their iPads and from books in the library. That
spontaneous lesson became the highlight of the week, in addition to several
students having fun repeating HAL’s “I’m sorry, Dave…” response during the
week.
These future
leaders are some very bright and inquisitive minds, possessing terrific senses
of humor too!